business, office, training, problem, solution, ask, who, how, what, where, when, why, woman, lecturer, presentation, whiteboard, board, write, work, company, professional, creative, training, training, problem, solution, how, why, presentation, presentation, presentation, presentation, presentation, whiteboard
Photo by geralt on Pixabay

Proposal Comparison

Part of Agency search by project type

Comparing agencies: questions for a multi-location business

Compare agencies on location information, local exceptions and the customer journey across a multi-location business.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Desk Selection.

Questions to ask when comparing agencies

Compare agencies on how they keep each location's information accurate while handling genuine local differences. Ask every candidate who approves a change, where approved facts are stored, and how errors are found and corrected. A national campaign example alone does not show the workflow will operate across your locations.

Choose locations that reveal the variation

Prepare the facts customers need for each location: name, address and phone, service area, contact route, hours, services, and the booking or enquiry destination. Mark which fields are controlled centrally and which local teams may change. Include different operating types where they exist, such as staffed shops and teams that visit customers.

Choose a small sample for candidate discussions: a routine location, one with a different service or schedule, and one whose information has been difficult to maintain. These are evaluation cases for your business to select, not tests an agency has already passed.

Ask which directories each field must match, and who checks that name, address and phone stay consistent across every directory at every location (searchscope.com.au). Ask what the agency needs from your team to keep that check running after the first cleanup.

Ask candidates to trace a multi-location update

Have each agency explain how a verified change would reach the website and any relevant profiles or campaign destinations. Ask who confirms the new fact, which records are updated, what happens when a branch and head office disagree, and who checks the result.

Ask candidates how they would assess your actual locations before any profiles are proposed, and what your business must confirm first. Ask what happens if a profile is suspended, what a suspension playbook sets out, and how reinstatement is handled (searchscope.com.au).

Ask how the portfolio will be held: which single account owns every profile, which managers are added per location, and how access is mapped so a departing manager cannot walk off with a listing. Ask for the standing procedure for openings, closures and relocations (searchscope.com.au).

Ask candidates to describe their proposed approach to profile management and what your business would need to confirm at the start. A promise to 'fix local listings' needs a defined set of locations, a change process and an account of what depends on your team or a third party. Ask which directories they update and who keeps name, address and phone consistent at every location (searchscope.com.au).

Compare the local customer path

Give candidates the same sample locations. Ask how a customer would find the correct site, see the right offer and reach the right team or booking process. Ask each agency where it sits on multi-location SEO, the practice of optimising one business with two or more physical locations so that each location ranks in the local results for its own area (searchscope.com.au).

If Google Business Profile action links are proposed, ask candidates to demonstrate where each link would take a customer and how it supports the intended action for that location. Treat this as a question about profile links, not a general website layout rule.

Ask whether reviews run per branch or pool at the flagship, and whether each location gets its own Google Business Profile, its own page, its own reviews and its own local signals (searchscope.com.au). Ask how the pages are structured so an AI answer can quote the right location.

Put the same questions to every candidate in writing. Who owns the master record for each location, and where is it stored? How will the sample locations be treated without inventing differences between them, and which people do the work?

How is performance reported for each location, and how is missing data handled? What happens if a profile goes down, and who corrects an incorrect listing or booking link (searchscope.com.au)?

An agency may run campaigns well while relying on your team to maintain location details. That can work if your team accepts the role and has capacity. Equally, a profile manager may depend on another team to repair an incorrect booking destination. Make those handovers clear before comparing fees.

Ask what a further location adds to the fee and to the workload, and what sits outside the quoted scope. Ask how the fee is structured as locations open, close or relocate.

Shortlist agencies whose proposed workflow can handle both a routine network update and a local exception. Ask finalists to describe the initial set of locations in scope and how further locations would change the work. Leave unverified location facts for the business owner to confirm.

Ask finalists for artefacts rather than assurances: an audit spreadsheet covering the sample locations, a sample location report and a change log from a comparable network. Ask who would keep that change log current once the work is live.

More from Proposal Comparison