Group of young professionals working together in a modern office setting, using laptops and technology.
Photo by Ofspace LLC, Culture on Pexels

Proposal Comparison

Choosing a digital agency in Australia

A practical way to shortlist and choose an Australian digital agency by matching the team, evidence and working arrangement to your business need.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Desk Selection.

undefined

When choosing a digital agency in Australia, start with the work your business needs next and with how you will check the candidates who bid for it. Verify each one against public registers, then compare proposals on the same questions. A broad service list, polished case study or low headline fee cannot answer those questions on its own.

Start with the decision you need help making

Describe the business problem before naming a channel. A retailer with poor repeat purchasing may need a different investigation from one whose website cannot take orders reliably.

Write down the intended customer, the result that matters, the deadline and the constraints the provider must work within. Include what your team can supply and approve.

You need not design the agency's solution. You do need enough clarity to recognise a proposal that addresses your problem. If the immediate task is uncertain, consider a bounded diagnostic engagement before committing to ongoing production.

Next decide what shape of help fits. A specialist may suit a defined technical or channel problem. A full-service agency may suit work that needs several disciplines coordinated. An independent consultant may suit a focused advisory task when your team can implement the advice.

These are buying choices, not quality grades. Ask each candidate who would perform the work and how gaps would be covered.

Put that into a short brief or request for proposal before you approach anyone, including the budget you can commit. Use the same document with every candidate so proposals can be compared against one another.

Build a shortlist on evidence you can verify

Look for providers whose work resembles your challenge in its constraints, not merely its industry label. A website example is more useful when it shows a similar platform, approval process or integration problem. Draw candidates from referrals, a pitch process or an open tender.

Ask what the provider was responsible for, who did the work and which results can reasonably be attributed to it. Treat a case study as a starting point for questions, not a forecast for your business.

Check each shortlisted provider the same way, and verify the basics yourself:

Check capability by asking the proposed team to explain the work, its dependencies and the choices it would make first. Check capacity by confirming who is available during your timeframe and who covers an absence or specialist gap. Test fit against your approval process, systems and staff; ask for relevant work and a reference willing to discuss the relationship. Finally, confirm deliverables, assumptions and costs.

Before the first call, check the candidate's ABN on ABN Lookup, any ISO certificates on the JAS-ANZ register and any vendor partner listing such as the Google Partners directory (PWD). Ask for dated case studies, a live account walkthrough, references and a written definition of what counts as a result and who verifies it (PWD).

Have the same useful conversation with each candidate

Give candidates the same account of the problem and the same material constraints. Ask each to explain its first decisions, what it needs from your team and what would make its proposed approach change. A useful answer distinguishes known facts from assumptions. If a provider promises an outcome, ask which parts it controls and how the result would be measured.

If proposals involve digital advertising or customer data, compare what each says about consent, data minimisation, data governance and compliance with data breach laws. The Australian Digital Advertising Practices: 2020 Update, prepared by AANA, IAB and MFA, sets out these topics in its consumer privacy checklist, including managing consent and control and sourcing data ethically and transparently (IAB Australia).

Meet the people expected to lead and perform the work, where practical. Ask who will make strategic decisions, who will produce the work and who will be accountable for correcting it. If subcontractors are involved, clarify their role and the agency's responsibility for them. Do not assume a person shown at the pitch will remain on the account.

A short paid discovery project can be appropriate when the problem cannot yet be scoped responsibly. Agree a fixed fee and an output you can use, such as a diagnosis with options, dependencies and costs. A proposed discovery project is not evidence of delivery until the work is done.

Decide against your priorities

Set aside non-negotiables and identify where acceptable candidates can differ. For example, experience with an essential system may be mandatory, while routine meeting location may be a preference. Put proposals side by side in a table: list each requirement, the evidence offered and whether it is included, assumed, excluded or not evidenced. Record the basis for each judgement so presentation style does not decide.

Ask finalists to state what is included, what depends on your team, what is excluded and how a changed requirement would be handled. Compare the whole proposed arrangement side by side, including deliverables, assumptions, staff time and price. A cheaper offer may be suitable if its narrower scope meets your need; a broader offer is valuable only if you will use the additional work.

Agencies commonly charge in five ways: hourly, monthly retainer, project fee, percentage of ad spend and performance-based fee (PWD). Ask each finalist to quote the same scope on the same model so the numbers can be compared.

Ask whether each quote includes GST. GST is a tax of 10% on most goods, services and other items sold or consumed in Australia. If an agency is registered for GST, it has to collect this extra money (one-eleventh of the sale price) from its customers (business.gov.au).

A law to protect small businesses from unfair terms in business-to-business standard form contracts took effect across Australia on 12 November 2016 (ACCC). If you think a term is unfair, ask for it to be removed or amended, contact your state or territory consumer protection agency or the Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman, or call the ACCC's small business helpline on 1300 302 021 (ACCC).

Name an internal owner and record why the chosen provider fits, what remains uncertain and when to review the relationship. Before work begins, settle the written scope, the notice each side must give, how the contract renews and how liability is handled. The ACCC's review of selected industries discusses unilateral variation, termination clauses, automatic renewal and wide indemnities in small-business contracts; treat these as review prompts for the agency's terms (ACCC).

Agree in writing what you will own and what happens when the engagement ends (PWD). Name the assets at stake, including the domain, ad accounts, analytics, content and any custom code, and say how each transfers and who keeps access.

In this guide

  1. Defining the work before searching for an agencyDefine the problem, outcome, constraints and internal contribution before looking for a digital agency.
  2. Specialist agency versus full-service agencyCompare specialist and full-service agencies by the depth of work required, the coordination your team can provide and who owns each handover.
  3. Deciding whether to hire an agency or an independent consultantChoose between an agency and independent consultant by checking the work, implementation capacity, continuity and accountability you need.

More from Proposal Comparison

Proposal Comparison

Comparing agency proposals

Compare agency proposals on scope, approach, team, dependencies and total cost. Clarify gaps and record a decision you can explain.